Gotthard Deutsch (1859–1921) taught at Hebrew Union College in Cincinnati from 1891 until his death, where he produced a card index of 70,000 ‘facts’ of Jewish history. This article explores the biography of this artefact of research and poses the following question: Does Deutsch’s index constitute a great unwritten work of history, as some have claimed, or are the cards ultimately useless ‘chips from his workshop’? It may seem a curious relic of positivistic history, but closer examination allows us to interrogate the materiality of scholarly labor. The catalogue constitutes a total archive and highlights memory’s multiple registers, as both a prosthesis for personal recall and a symbol of a ‘human encyclopedia’. The article argues that this mostly forgotten scholar’s work had surprising repercussions: Deutsch’s student Jacob Rader Marcus (1896–1995) brought his teacher’s emphasis on facticity to the field of American Jewish history that he pioneered, catapulting a 19th-century positivism to the threshold of the 21st century. Deutsch’s index was at an inflection point of knowledge production, created as historians were shifting away from ‘facts’ but just before new technologies (also based on cards) enabled ‘big data’ on a larger scale. The article thus excavates a vision of monumentality but proposes we look past these objects as monuments to ‘heroic’ scholarship. Indeed, Deutsch’s index is massive but middling, especially when placed alongside those of Niklas Luhmann, Paul Otlet, or Gershom Scholem. It thus presents a necessary corrective to anointing such indexes as predecessors to the Internet and big data because we must keep their problematic positivism in perspective.
In honor of Yom Kippur today, I’m celebrating with acknowledgement of Gotthard Deutsch’s “monumental card index [zettelkasten] of Jewish history”. I hope everyone had an easy fast.
5 thoughts on “”
In honor of Yom Kippur today, I’m celebrating with acknowledgement of Gotthard Deutsch’s “monumental card index of Jewish history” (70,000 cards!). #Zettelkasten
I hope everyone had an easy fast.
Incidentally, there’s a free version of the paper at https://www.academia.edu/39896787/_Mere_Chips_From_His_Workshop_Gotthard_Deutsch_s_Monumental_Card_Index_of_Jewish_History and it’s got a great photo of his physical files on page 5. The picture shows 38 drawers, but the text indicates there are around 50.
@chrisaldrich You might like this, too: “The slip box presently contains 1.5 million slips referring to 12 million references;” https://agate.academy/projects.html?tx_agate_projects%5Baction%5D=show&tx_agate_projects%5Bcontroller%5D=Projects&tx_agate_projects%5Bquery%5D=deaf&tx_agate_projects%5Bsubmit%5D=Search&tx_agate_projects%5BitemsPerPage%5D=20&tx_agate_projects%5Bproject%5D=101&cHash=2c8e0b07c047b4827297610e7f63a9e8Unfortunately I didn’t find a photo of their impressive cabinet.
Altfranzösisches etymologisches Wörterbuch : AGATE
@x28de Thanks Matthias. This is great! 🗃️